Crypto attorney analyzes the bear case for a spot Ether ETF approval in May

March 13, 2024 | by


In the world of cryptocurrency, the potential approval of a Spot Ether ETF in May has garnered significant attention. However, amidst the excitement, a bear case has emerged, and it is this case that crypto attorney Jake Chervinsky aims to analyze. Chervinsky, renowned for his expertise in the legal aspects of cryptocurrency, dissects the potential challenges that may hinder the approval of a Spot Ether ETF in May. By providing a thorough examination of the bear case, Chervinsky offers valuable insights into the potential roadblocks and implications that investors and enthusiasts should be aware of.

Overview of the Spot Ether ETF

A spot Ether exchange-traded fund (ETF) is the recent hot topic in the world of cryptocurrency. It is an investment vehicle that allows investors to gain exposure to the price movements of Ether, the native cryptocurrency of the Ethereum blockchain, without actually owning the digital asset itself. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is currently considering the approval of a spot Ether ETF, and the decision to be announced in May 2023 is highly anticipated by investors and industry experts alike.

Explanation of a spot Ether ETF

A spot Ether ETF operates by holding and managing a portfolio of physical Ether tokens. It enables investors to trade or invest in Ether without directly owning the cryptocurrency. Instead, they can buy shares of the ETF on an exchange, where the price of the shares is determined by the value of the underlying Ether assets. This allows investors to gain exposure to the potential upside of Ether’s price movements without the need to hold and secure the asset themselves.


Importance of the approval in May

The approval of a spot Ether ETF in May would be a significant milestone for the cryptocurrency industry. It would provide institutional and retail investors with a regulated and easily accessible avenue to invest in Ether, potentially leading to increased market liquidity and broader adoption of the cryptocurrency. Moreover, the approval would signal a growing acceptance and recognition of cryptocurrencies by traditional financial institutions and regulators, further legitimizing the asset class.

Introduction to Crypto Attorney Jake Chervinsky

Jake Chervinsky is a well-respected attorney specializing in cryptocurrency regulation and litigation. With years of experience in the field, Chervinsky has become a prominent figure in the cryptocurrency community. He serves as the General Counsel at Compound Labs, a decentralized finance (DeFi) protocol, and frequently provides his legal analysis and insights on various regulatory matters impacting the crypto space.


Background and expertise of Jake Chervinsky

Chervinsky’s expertise lies in the complex legal landscape surrounding cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology. He has been involved in several high-profile cases and has contributed to the understanding and development of crypto regulations. Chervinsky’s knowledge stems from his previous work as a litigator in the U.S. federal government, where he focused on enforcement actions involving financial crimes and securities fraud.

Why his analysis is important

Given Chervinsky’s deep understanding of regulatory frameworks and his experience in the crypto industry, his analysis and insights hold great importance. He has a reputation for providing balanced perspectives, taking into account both legal and practical considerations. Chervinsky’s analysis helps investors and market participants comprehend the potential hurdles and outcomes of regulatory decisions, such as the approval of a spot Ether ETF.


Analysis of the Bear Case

While the prospect of a spot Ether ETF approval generates excitement, it is essential to consider the potential risks and concerns associated with such a development. Chervinsky has outlined what he refers to as the “bear case” for the approval of a spot Ether ETF, which encompasses several factors that might hinder the SEC’s decision.

Regulatory Concerns

One of the primary concerns surrounding the approval of a spot Ether ETF is the SEC’s cautious approach towards cryptocurrency-related investment products. The SEC has a history of rejecting or delaying the approval of crypto ETFs due to concerns regarding market manipulation, investor protection, and custody of underlying assets. These concerns make it challenging for cryptocurrency ETF issuers to meet the criteria necessary for regulatory approval.


Complexity of regulating spot Ether ETFs

Regulating spot Ether ETFs is particularly intricate due to the unique characteristics of cryptocurrencies. The decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies, combined with the potential for price manipulation and fraud, poses challenges for regulators. The SEC must strike a balance between facilitating innovation and protecting investors, which requires a comprehensive understanding of the crypto market and the underlying technology.

Market Volatility

Another significant factor that contributes to the bear case against a spot Ether ETF approval is the high volatility of the cryptocurrency market. Cryptocurrencies are notorious for their price fluctuations, which can be rapid and extreme. The SEC may hesitate to approve an investment product that exposes investors to such volatility, as it increases the risk of financial loss and potential market instability.

Potential risks to investors

The volatile nature of cryptocurrencies not only exposes investors to potential short-term losses but also raises concerns about the long-term stability and sustainability of crypto markets. Cryptocurrency exchanges and markets are prone to hacking and cybersecurity breaches, which could result in substantial financial losses for investors. The lack of regulatory oversight and investor protections further exacerbates these risks, making it challenging for the SEC to grant approval for a spot Ether ETF.

Lack of Precedent

The absence of approved cryptocurrency ETFs presents another obstacle for the approval of a spot Ether ETF. As of now, the SEC has not granted approval to any crypto ETF, including those based on Bitcoin. The lack of precedent makes it difficult to establish a clear regulatory framework for spot Ether ETFs. Consequently, the SEC may be hesitant to approve a product without robust guidelines in place.

Challenges of establishing a new regulatory framework

Creating a suitable regulatory framework for spot Ether ETFs involves overcoming various challenges. Regulators need to address concerns related to custody, market manipulation, transparency, and investor protection. Establishing these guidelines is a complex and time-consuming process, as it requires extensive consultations with industry experts, market participants, and other stakeholders. The absence of an established framework significantly adds to the SEC’s deliberation on spot Ether ETF approval.

Recent Developments

In recent times, the SEC has shown a greater openness and willingness to engage with the crypto industry. The regulatory body has been actively discussing the potential benefits and risks associated with crypto ETFs. While the SEC remains cautious, the growing interest from institutional investors and the demand for regulated investment products have brought the topic of crypto ETFs to the forefront of regulatory discussions.

SEC’s stance on crypto ETFs

The SEC has consistently emphasized the importance of investor protection and market integrity in the context of crypto ETFs. While they have not yet approved any cryptocurrency ETF, they have outlined conditions that need to be satisfied for such approval. These conditions include adequate market surveillance, robust custody solutions, and measures to prevent fraud and manipulation. By taking a deliberate and cautious approach, the SEC aims to strike a balance between fostering innovation and protecting investors.

Impact of SEC’s decision on Ether ETF approval

The SEC’s decision on a spot Ether ETF in May will have far-reaching implications for the crypto market. If approved, it would open up a new avenue for investment, potentially attracting a significant influx of capital into the Ether market. The increased liquidity and accessibility might also contribute to a more efficient price discovery process for Ether. On the other hand, a rejection or further delay in approval could lead to short-term market volatility and potential disappointment among investors eagerly awaiting an ETF opportunity.

Counterarguments to the Bear Case

While the bear case raises valid concerns, there are also counterarguments that suggest the potential approval of a spot Ether ETF in May.

Growing institutional interest in cryptocurrencies

Institutional interest in cryptocurrencies has been on the rise, with major financial institutions and corporations exploring ways to enter the crypto market. This growing institutional involvement brings credibility and stability to the market, which could positively influence the SEC’s decision-making regarding a spot Ether ETF. The increasing demand from sophisticated investors may prompt regulators to consider approving investment products that cater to institutional needs.

Positive regulatory developments in the crypto space

The crypto regulatory landscape has been evolving rapidly, with various jurisdictions implementing clearer guidelines and regulations for cryptocurrencies. For instance, the approval of Bitcoin futures ETFs in the United States indicates a shifting regulatory sentiment towards crypto investment products. These positive developments increase the prospects of a spot Ether ETF approval, as they demonstrate an improving regulatory environment for cryptocurrencies.


The approval of a spot Ether ETF is eagerly anticipated by investors and industry participants. While the bear case highlights legitimate concerns such as regulatory uncertainties, market volatility, and lack of precedent, counterarguments suggest a changing landscape with growing institutional interest and evolving regulations. The decision by the SEC in May will likely shape the future of the cryptocurrency market, either by opening up new investment opportunities or potentially leading to short-term market turbulence. As the crypto community eagerly awaits the SEC’s verdict, it is a testament to the significance and maturation of the cryptocurrency industry.


Chervinsky, J. (2022, December 1). Crypto Attorney Jake Chervinsky Explains the Bear Case for a Spot Ether ETF Approval in May. Finance Bitcoin News. Retrieved from [link to be added].



View all

view all