How Hertz’s bets on Tesla and a Goldman veteran veered off course

March 21, 2024 | by


In “How Hertz’s bets on Tesla and a Goldman veteran veered off course,” the article explores the missteps and challenges faced by Hertz in its attempt to incorporate Tesla vehicles into its rental fleet. The involvement of a former Goldman Sachs executive added prestige to the venture, but unexpected issues arose that hindered the company’s plans. The article delves into the factors that contributed to Hertz’s struggles and how they impacted the company’s relationship with Tesla and its overall business strategy.


In recent years, Hertz, the renowned car rental company, made strategic bets on Tesla vehicles and a Goldman veteran to revitalize its business. These decisions were aimed at leveraging cutting-edge technology and expertise in order to gain a competitive edge in the car rental industry. However, these bets veered off course, leading to significant financial troubles and challenges for Hertz. This article will explore the background of Hertz, its decision to order Tesla vehicles, the involvement of a Goldman veteran, the issues and challenges faced, the impact on Hertz’s financial performance, lessons learned, recovery efforts, future prospects, and conclude on the overall outlook for Hertz.

Background of Hertz

History of Hertz

Hertz, founded in 1918, has established itself as a global leader in the car rental industry. Over the years, it has built a strong brand and a vast network of rental locations worldwide. Hertz has prided itself on providing high-quality vehicles and excellent customer service to its diverse customer base.


Financial troubles

Despite its long-standing reputation, Hertz faced financial troubles in recent years. The rise of ride-sharing services and evolving consumer preferences had a significant impact on the car rental industry. Hertz struggled to adapt to these changes, leading to declining revenue and profitability. These financial troubles put immense pressure on the company to find innovative solutions to turn the tide.

The Bet on Tesla

Hertz’s decision to order Tesla vehicles

In an effort to stay ahead of the curve and appeal to environmentally conscious consumers, Hertz made a bold decision to order a large fleet of Tesla electric vehicles. This partnership with Tesla was intended to showcase Hertz’s commitment to sustainability and provide its customers with a premium electric vehicle rental option.


Expected benefits of the partnership

Hertz anticipated several benefits from this partnership. Firstly, the Tesla vehicles were expected to attract a new segment of environmentally conscious customers, expanding Hertz’s customer base. Additionally, the partnership was viewed as an opportunity to enhance the company’s brand image and differentiate itself from competitors. Lastly, Hertz anticipated cost savings from reduced fuel expenses and maintenance costs associated with electric vehicles.

Challenges in implementing the Tesla fleet

Implementing a large fleet of Tesla vehicles presented several challenges for Hertz. Firstly, the limited availability of charging infrastructure posed a challenge for Hertz to ensure convenient and efficient charging for its rental vehicles. Furthermore, the higher upfront cost of Tesla vehicles compared to traditional gasoline-powered vehicles added financial strain to Hertz’s operations. Lastly, Hertz needed to educate its employees and customers about the unique features and operation of electric vehicles.


The Role of a Goldman Veteran

The hiring of a Goldman veteran

To navigate the complex challenges and execute its strategy effectively, Hertz made a significant hire by bringing in a veteran from Goldman Sachs. This hire was seen as an opportunity to leverage the individual’s expertise in finance, strategy, and industry knowledge to drive Hertz’s turnaround efforts.

Expectations for the veteran’s impact on Hertz’s strategy

The hiring of the Goldman veteran raised expectations for Hertz’s strategic direction. It was anticipated that the veteran would bring a fresh perspective, streamline operations, optimize cost structures, and identify new growth opportunities. With their extensive experience in the financial industry, the veteran was also expected to help Hertz navigate its financial troubles and improve its overall financial stability.


The execution of the strategy

Despite high expectations, the execution of the strategy led by the Goldman veteran faced significant challenges. The technical difficulties with the Tesla vehicles, cost overruns, and competitive pressures in the car rental industry created obstacles that hindered the effective implementation of Hertz’s strategic plan. These challenges ultimately impacted Hertz’s financial performance and impeded its recovery efforts.

Issues and Challenges

Technical difficulties with the Tesla vehicles

Hertz encountered technical difficulties with the Tesla vehicles, ranging from charging infrastructure limitations to reliability issues. The limited availability of charging stations meant that Hertz had to carefully plan routes and charging schedules for its fleet, which posed challenges in meeting customer demands. Moreover, the reliability issues with the Tesla vehicles led to customer dissatisfaction and increased maintenance costs for Hertz.

Cost overruns and financial strains

The decision to invest in a large fleet of Tesla vehicles led to significant cost overruns for Hertz. The higher upfront cost of electric vehicles, combined with the need for additional charging infrastructure and maintenance expenses, strained Hertz’s financial resources. These cost overruns exacerbated the company’s financial troubles and hampered its ability to invest in other areas of its business.

Competitive pressures in the car rental industry

Alongside the challenges specific to the Tesla fleet, Hertz also faced intense competitive pressures in the car rental industry as a whole. The emergence of ride-sharing services and the shift in consumer preferences towards on-demand mobility options presented significant challenges to Hertz’s traditional business model. Competitors were offering innovative solutions, such as flexible car rentals and subscription-based services, further intensifying the competitive landscape.

Impact on Hertz’s Financial Performance

Decline in revenue and profitability

The issues and challenges faced by Hertz had a substantial impact on its financial performance. The declining revenue and profitability, coupled with the cost overruns and competitive pressures, resulted in significant financial losses for the company. Hertz struggled to generate sufficient cash flow to cover its expenses and service its debt, leading to a deteriorating financial situation.

Stock price performance

Hertz’s financial troubles were reflected in its stock price performance. The company experienced a significant decline in its share price as investors reacted to the challenges and uncertainties surrounding Hertz’s future. The declining stock price further exacerbated the company’s financial strain, as it limited its ability to raise capital through equity offerings.

Credit rating downgrades

Hertz’s financial troubles and deteriorating financial performance led to credit rating downgrades by major credit rating agencies. These downgrades made it more difficult and costly for Hertz to access debt markets and secure favorable financing terms. The credit rating downgrades also eroded investor confidence, further impacting Hertz’s ability to raise funds and address its financial challenges.

Lessons Learned

Strategic risks and considerations

Hertz’s experience with the Tesla partnership and the Goldman veteran highlighted the importance of carefully evaluating strategic risks and considerations. It is crucial for companies to thoroughly assess the potential challenges and implications associated with new technologies, partnerships, and industry dynamics. A comprehensive understanding of the potential risks can inform more effective risk mitigation strategies and improve decision-making processes.

Effective partnerships and collaborations

The Tesla partnership showcased the potential benefits of effective partnerships and collaborations. However, it also demonstrated the importance of aligning expectations, ensuring sufficient resources and capabilities to support the partnership, and proactively addressing challenges. Building strong relationships and fostering open communication channels are critical factors for successful collaborations.

Importance of financial stability

Hertz’s financial troubles underscored the critical role of financial stability in a company’s success. Sound financial management and risk mitigation strategies are essential for weathering challenges, maintaining investor confidence, and accessing capital markets. Establishing a strong financial foundation can enhance a company’s ability to navigate industry disruptions and pursue growth opportunities.

Hertz’s Recovery Efforts

Management changes and restructuring

To address its financial troubles and chart a path to recovery, Hertz implemented management changes and embarked on a restructuring process. New leadership was brought in to drive strategic decision-making and operational improvements. Additionally, the company implemented cost-cutting measures, such as reducing its workforce and optimizing its rental fleet, to improve its financial performance and enhance efficiency.

Efforts to reduce debt and improve liquidity

Hertz focused on reducing its debt burden and improving its liquidity position as part of its recovery efforts. The company pursued refinancing options, negotiated with its lenders, and explored asset sales to generate cash and improve its balance sheet. These efforts aimed to enhance Hertz’s financial flexibility and provide the resources necessary for its ongoing operations and investment in future growth.

Exploration of new business opportunities

In addition to addressing its financial challenges, Hertz actively explored new business opportunities to diversify its revenue streams and adapt to evolving customer preferences. The company explored partnerships with ride-sharing platforms, car subscription services, and other mobility solutions to expand its offerings and reach new customer segments. By embracing innovation and adapting to changing industry dynamics, Hertz aimed to position itself for long-term success.

Future Prospects

Challenges and opportunities in the car rental industry

The car rental industry continues to face challenges and opportunities. The rise of ride-sharing services and the growing popularity of alternative transportation options present ongoing challenges to traditional car rental companies like Hertz. However, the increasing demand for flexibility, convenience, and sustainable transportation solutions also creates opportunities for innovation and differentiation.

Expected impact of electric vehicles on the industry

Electric vehicles are poised to have a significant impact on the car rental industry. As consumers become more environmentally conscious and governments implement stricter emission regulations, the demand for electric vehicles is expected to increase. Car rental companies like Hertz have an opportunity to capitalize on this trend by offering electric vehicle rental options and investing in charging infrastructure.

Long-term outlook for Hertz

While Hertz has faced significant challenges, the company’s recovery efforts and exploration of new business opportunities provide a glimmer of hope for its long-term prospects. By leveraging its brand, global presence, and customer relationships, Hertz has the potential to adapt to changing industry dynamics and rebuild its financial stability. However, success will depend on effective execution of its strategies, continued innovation, and agility in adapting to evolving customer preferences and industry trends.


Hertz’s bets on Tesla vehicles and a Goldman veteran veered off course, leading to financial troubles and challenges for the company. Despite the difficulties faced, Hertz’s experience offers important lessons about strategic risks and considerations, effective partnerships, and financial stability. The company’s recovery efforts, including management changes, debt reduction, and exploration of new business opportunities, provide hope for its future prospects. As the car rental industry continues to evolve, Hertz’s ability to adapt, innovate, and provide value to customers will be crucial for its long-term success.



View all

view all